# From shortlist to hire

> Practical guidance on outreach, interview design and offers when hiring from Ewance. Ewance stays out of your way after the first message, but the interview should look different when you have read the work.

You have found someone whose shipped work fits the role. Now what?

This page is the recruiter-side playbook from first outreach to signed offer. Ewance steps out of the way after the first message. These are field notes from teams who have done it well.

## Outreach: tell them which work caught your eye

The single most useful piece of advice on this page: **never send a generic message.**

A weak message:

> Hi Sara, I came across your profile on Ewance and would love to chat about a role at [Company]. Are you free this week?

A strong message:

> Hi Sara, your market-entry analysis on Spanish solar caught my eye because we are hiring an analyst for our renewables team in Madrid. The way you sized regulatory cost separately from competitor cost is exactly the structure we would ask you to apply to our actual pipeline. Are you in conversations right now, or would you want to talk in a week or two?

The second message takes a minute or two longer to write and gets far more replies. Read at least one full submission before you message. Reference something specific. Tell them why their work fits.

This is the muscle Ewance asks recruiters to build. The reward is candidates who reply, take the conversation seriously and do not disappear between outreach and interview.

## Set timing expectations

Students are often juggling other things: coursework, exams, term breaks, other roles. Be explicit about:

- **What stage you are at**: first conversation, formal interview loop, or just keeping warm.
- **The role's start date**: flexible, fixed to a graduation date, or immediate.
- **Pay and seniority**: junior analyst pay expectations are very different from new-graduate engineer pay expectations. Naming a range up front saves both sides time.

Give candidates a fair chance to reply, and a polite second message is fine. After two unanswered messages, move on. The etiquette norm is that silence means "not interested right now".

## Interview design when you have already seen the work

Standard early-stage interviews lean on "tell me about a project you are proud of". When you have already read the project, that question is wasted air.

Things to do instead:

### 1. Treat the submission as the take-home

You have already seen it. Now have them walk you through it. *"In your Spanish solar analysis, walk me through how you would update the regulatory cost section if I told you the policy changed last week."* This tests their thinking on familiar ground. You learn whether the work was theirs or whether they coasted on a teammate.

### 2. Stress-test a specific decision

Pick one decision in their submission and probe it. *"You decided to exclude small-scale solar from your sizing. Why? Was that judgment, or did you not have the data?"* You learn how they reason under push-back.

### 3. Skip the standard "weakness" routine

Candidates who have shipped challenge work are already people who can do the work. Asking them to perform humility wastes both your time and theirs. Ask about specific failures or hard moments instead: *"In which step of this challenge did you feel most stuck, and what got you unstuck?"*

### 4. Save your normal screen for what the credential does not prove

The credential proves they can ship a market analysis. It does not prove they can present it to a hostile stakeholder. It does not prove they communicate well in writing under deadline pressure. It does not prove they are easy to work with. **Interview for those.**

## Offers and rejections

Standard rules apply. Ewance has no opinion on your offer process. A few things worth saying:

- **Move quickly.** Strong candidates often have several conversations going. Do not leave them waiting after the final interview.
- **Reject with feedback.** Students who put real work into a challenge appreciate feedback when they do not get the role. *"Strong analysis, but we are prioritising someone with more direct exposure to regulated industries. Try us again in a year"* is better than a form-letter rejection. They will remember and may apply for the next opening.
- **Stay in touch with runners-up.** The second-best candidate for one role is often the best candidate for a related role later.

## After the hire

The platform does not track post-hire outcomes. We trust you to do well by your new hires, and you trust us to keep surfacing strong candidates.

## What about referrals?

Many recruiters land good hires when an existing candidate refers a classmate or labmate whose work is not yet on the platform. You can encourage the referee to sign up and build a portfolio.

Either way, the conversation is not bound by what is currently in the platform. You are recruiting people, and we are surfacing signals. The signals are useful. They are not the entire toolset.

## You have reached the end of the companies section

If you want to deepen the relationship by putting your team's actual problem shapes in front of students, see [ewance.com/companies](https://ewance.com/companies/) for sponsorship.

For verification mechanics, look back at [Verified credentials](/docs/companies/verified-credentials.md). For terms, see the [glossary](/docs/reference/glossary.md).
