Formative assessment
Formative assessment checks learning while it is happening, to give feedback and adjust teaching. Summative assessment judges it at the end, as a grade or a pass.
What formative assessment is
Formative assessment checks learning while it is happening, so that students and teachers can adjust. It is usually low stakes: a draft, a quick quiz, a question in class, a short check-in with feedback.
Summative assessment, by contrast, judges what was learned at the end, as a grade or a pass.
- DraftLow stakes
- FeedbackSpecific and timely
- ReviseAct on it
- FeedbackCheck progress
- Final gradeSummative: the result
What the research says
In their 1998 review Inside the Black Box, Paul Black and Dylan Wiliam concluded that improving formative assessment raises student achievement, reporting effect sizes between 0.4 and 0.7 across the studies they reviewed. That is larger than most educational changes. The finding has been refined since, and the quality of the feedback matters as much as the amount.
Common formative methods
Some of the simplest methods work well:
- Questions that make thinking visible, asked during teaching.
- Drafts with comments before a final version.
- Low-stakes quizzes used for feedback, not grades.
- Peer review against a clear rubric.
- Short reflections: what is clear, what is still confusing.
Formative assessment in the AI era
When a polished final answer is easy to produce, the process becomes more informative than the product. Drafts, decision notes and conversations show how a student is thinking. That is formative evidence, and it also makes it clearer when AI has done the thinking.
What good feedback looks like
Useful feedback is specific, timely and points to a next step. It says what is working, what is missing and what to try next, and it arrives while the student can still act on it.
An example
Illustrative case: students write a one-page plan for a small project. A week before the final version the teacher returns comments on two points: the goal is vague and one claim has no source. Students revise using the comments. Nothing was graded at that stage, yet the final work is stronger and the teacher knows who needs more help.
Common mistakes
- Grading every formative task, which makes students avoid risk.
- Giving feedback too late to use.
- Giving only scores or praise with no next step.
- Treating formative assessment as extra marking instead of part of teaching.
Formative vs summative assessment
Formative assessment is for learning: it informs the next step. Summative assessment is of learning: it records the result. The same task can serve both if feedback comes before the grade. Good courses plan both on purpose.
Frequently asked questions
- Is a quiz formative or summative?
- It depends on its use. A quiz used to give feedback and change teaching is formative. The same quiz used for a final grade is summative.
- Does formative assessment need to be graded?
- Usually not. Marks can make students focus on scores instead of improvement.
- How does formative assessment help with AI use?
- Drafts, reflections and conversations along the way show the student's own thinking and give teachers a chance to talk about appropriate AI use.