Inquiry-Based Learning: Definition, Levels and Examples
Inquiry-based learning has students investigate questions instead of receiving answers. Here is what it is, the four levels of inquiry, what the evidence says about guidance, and how to use it.
The basics
What inquiry-based learning is
Inquiry-based learning is an approach in which students learn by investigating a question, problem or scenario instead of being handed the answer. They ask questions, look for evidence, build explanations and then test and reflect on them. The teacher's role shifts from telling to guiding.
It grows out of the ideas of John Dewey, who argued that learning starts from real problems, and of discovery learning, which Jerome Bruner promoted. It is used widely in science education and increasingly in other subjects, from history to business.
- ConfirmationStudents confirm a known result. Teacher gives the question and method.
- StructuredTeacher gives the question and method. Students find the answer.
- GuidedTeacher gives the question. Students design the method.
- OpenStudents choose the question and the method.
The four levels of inquiry
Not all inquiry is equally open. Researchers Banchi and Bell describe four levels based on how much the teacher supplies. At the lowest level, confirmation inquiry, students already know the expected result and practice a method. In structured inquiry, the teacher gives the question and the method and students find the answer. In guided inquiry, the teacher gives the question and students design the method. In open inquiry, students choose both.
Beginners generally need more structure. Moving up the levels as skills grow is a common way to build independence.
The inquiry cycle
Models differ, but most include the same movements:
- Question: start with a puzzling question, case or phenomenon.
- Investigate: gather evidence by experiment, reading, data or interviews.
- Explain: build an explanation or answer from the evidence.
- Test and extend: check it against new cases or other explanations.
- Reflect and share: say what was learned and how, and present it.
The well-known 5E instructional model, from the Biological Sciences Curriculum Study, follows a similar path: engage, explore, explain, elaborate and evaluate.
Evidence
Benefits
Used well, inquiry can:
- Build research, reasoning and problem-solving skills, not just recall.
- Increase engagement and ownership, because students pursue real questions.
- Develop habits such as questioning claims and checking evidence.
- Prepare students to work on open problems, where the answer is not in the textbook.
These benefits depend heavily on how well the inquiry is designed and supported.
What the evidence says: guidance matters
Inquiry-based learning is debated. In 2006, Kirschner, Sweller and Clark argued that minimally guided instruction is less effective for novices, because it asks them to search for knowledge while they are still learning the basics. Hmelo-Silver, Duncan and Chinn responded that well-scaffolded inquiry and problem-based learning are not minimal guidance and can work well.
A 2011 meta-analysis by Alfieri and colleagues found that unassisted discovery learning was generally less effective than explicit instruction, while enhanced discovery, where students get feedback, worked examples or other guidance, was more effective. The practical lesson is to structure inquiry, not to leave students alone with a question.
In practice
How to use inquiry in a course
A practical approach:
- Choose a question worth investigating, with more than one defensible answer.
- Match the level of inquiry to your students' experience.
- Teach the basic concepts and methods students will need before or alongside the inquiry.
- Give scaffolds: guiding questions, templates, checkpoints and examples of good work.
- Check understanding along the way with short feedback loops.
- Assess the reasoning and evidence as well as the result, using a clear rubric.
Examples
Inquiry looks different by subject:
- Science: students investigate why plants grow differently under different light and design the experiment.
- History: students compare two accounts of an event and decide which is better supported.
- Business: students analyze a company's customer data and recommend what to change.
- Computing: students find out why a program is slow, test hypotheses and report the cause.
Real company challenges are a form of inquiry, because the brief poses a question and students must decide how to investigate it.
Inquiry-based vs problem-based, project-based and discovery learning
The terms overlap. Inquiry-based learning centers on investigating a question. Problem-based learning starts from a complex problem and asks students to work out what they need to learn. Project-based learning centers on producing something over time. Discovery learning is the least guided end of the range, which is where the evidence is weakest.
Wrap-up
Common mistakes
- Leaving beginners with an open question and no structure.
- Asking questions that have a single answer the teacher already has in mind.
- Skipping the teaching of basic concepts that the inquiry needs.
- Assessing only the final answer and not the reasoning.
- Calling any hands-on activity inquiry without a real question.
Reference
Frequently asked questions
- What is inquiry-based learning?
- A teaching approach in which students learn by investigating questions and problems, gathering evidence and building explanations, with the teacher guiding the process.
- What are the four levels of inquiry?
- Confirmation, structured, guided and open inquiry, based on how much the teacher supplies: the question, the method and the answer.
- What are examples of inquiry-based learning?
- Designing an experiment to answer a science question, comparing historical accounts, analyzing company data and recommending a change, or diagnosing why a program is slow.
- Is inquiry-based learning effective?
- It can be, when it is well scaffolded. Research suggests that guided inquiry with feedback and support outperforms unguided discovery.
- What is the difference between inquiry-based and problem-based learning?
- Inquiry-based learning starts from a question to investigate. Problem-based learning starts from a complex problem and has students work out what they need to learn to solve it. The two overlap.
- How do you assess inquiry-based learning?
- Use a clear rubric that rates the question, the evidence, the reasoning and the reflection, in addition to the final result.
Sources
- Kirschner, Sweller and Clark (2006). Why minimal guidance during instruction does not work. Educational Psychologist
- Hmelo-Silver, Duncan and Chinn (2007). Scaffolding and achievement in problem-based and inquiry learning: A response to Kirschner, Sweller and Clark. Educational Psychologist
- Alfieri, Brooks, Aldrich and Tenenbaum (2011). Does discovery-based instruction enhance learning? Journal of Educational Psychology